Trial a new reward before a full programme change: Decide before launch whether to keep, revise or stop the new reward.; Randomly assign eligible members to the offer or to the current programme alone.; Check eligible claims, ineligible baskets, threshold cases, unavailable rewards and returns.
Image: Loyalty Marketing Guide

Programme Design

Part of Refreshing an existing loyalty programme

Testing a new reward before a full programme change

Plan a limited loyalty reward trial, protect current benefits, measure claims and decide what the evidence can support.

Loyalty Programme Desk · · 4 min read

Trial a proposed reward as a limited, clearly described offer before changing the standing programme. Keep existing entitlements intact, decide what the trial must teach you, and compare eligible members under consistent conditions. A trial can show whether the reward can be claimed and delivered; a claim that it changed purchasing needs a suitable comparison.

Limited reward trial workflow

  1. Specify offerDefine who qualifies, what they receive, when and where they can claim it, and any stock, booking or spend limits.
  2. Choose comparisonDecide how to compare eligible members under consistent conditions while keeping existing benefits available in both groups.
  3. Check claim pathTest eligible, ineligible, threshold, unavailable and cancellation or return scenarios before inviting members.
  4. Run limited offerKeep existing entitlements intact and record offer, claim, use, failure, cost and support data.
  5. Review and decideKeep, revise or stop the new reward; document how outstanding trial entitlements will be treated.

Specify the offer and decision

Write the proposed reward as a member would see it: who qualifies, what they receive, when and where they can claim it, and any stock, booking or spend limits. Decide whether it is an additional temporary offer or a proposed replacement. Trial messaging should not imply that an existing benefit has ended when it has not.

Choose one decision the trial will support: keep the new reward, revise it or stop it. Define eligible members, invitations, claim attempts, completed uses, failures, fulfilment cost and support contacts before launch. If the aim includes changed repeat purchasing, define that outcome and its observation period before reviewing results.

Define before launch

  • Eligible members
  • Invitations
  • Claim attempts
  • Completed uses
  • Failures
  • Fulfilment cost
  • Support contacts
  • Repeat-purchasing outcome and observation period, if relevant

Choose a comparison that fits the question

Where fair and practical, randomly assign eligible members to receive the additional offer or continue with the current programme alone. Keep existing benefits available in both groups. Compare all members as assigned, including those who never claim the trial reward. That assesses the effect of offering it to this group under the trial conditions.

A staged rollout can reveal delivery problems, but groups and trading periods may differ. Record promotions, price changes and stock problems. Interpret a purchasing difference in light of those limits. If no credible comparison is possible, report use and service outcomes without an incremental-sales claim.

Random assignment vs staged rollout

  • Random assignmentRandomly assign eligible members to receive the additional offer or continue with the current programme alone. Keep existing benefits in both groups. Compare all members as assigned, including those who never claim the trial reward.
  • Staged rolloutCan reveal delivery problems, but groups and trading periods may differ. Record promotions, price changes and stock problems. Interpret purchasing differences in light of those limits.
  • No credible comparisonReport use and service outcomes without an incremental-sales claim.

Check the claim path

Before inviting members, check an eligible claim, an ineligible basket, a member just below any threshold, an unavailable reward, and a cancellation or return. Compare what the member sees with the transaction and reward records. Assign an owner for stock or service capacity and a route for failed claims.

Record when a reward was offered, claimed, used or left open. Count an issued voucher separately from its later use. Tell members how long the trial lasts and what happens to a reward they earn before it ends.

Claim path checks before inviting members

  • Eligible claim
  • Ineligible basket
  • Member just below any threshold
  • Unavailable reward
  • Cancellation or return
  • Compare member view with transaction and reward records
  • Assign owner for stock or service capacity
  • Create route for failed claims
  • Record offered, claimed, used or left open
  • Count issued voucher separately from later use
  • Tell members how long the trial lasts and what happens to a reward they earn before it ends

Decide what to do next

Review member use beside failures, complaints, cost and the stated outcome. A reward with many claims but frequent delivery failures needs repair before expansion. A smooth claim path with little relevant use may need a different benefit or audience. Examine assignment, missing transactions and other changes before attributing a purchasing difference to the offer.

Document whether to keep, revise or stop the new reward and how outstanding trial entitlements will be treated. Then decide whether any standing rule should change. The result applies to the members, period and offer assessed; it does not rank rewards for every business.

Review before deciding next steps

  • Member use
  • Failures
  • Complaints
  • Cost
  • Stated outcome
  • Assignment
  • Missing transactions
  • Other changes
  • Document keep, revise or stop decision
  • Treat outstanding trial entitlements
  • Decide whether any standing rule should change

More from Programme Design